Comprehensive Overview for the Beginner
Although I do not actively practice aikido, I am an active, experienced martial artist. My current obsession is the Chinese internal martial arts. That being said, this was an interesting book for me.
I'd have to agree that this book is best for the beginner. It goes into significant detail about aikido history, traditions, etiquette, and concepts as well as philosophy. Very detailed!
It was interesting, because despite all that detail, once the techniques section started, it got very rudimentary. The explanations became somewhat superficial-- do this, switch to this, move this foot. Nothing about intention, energy, or key elements to the technique. The drawings were pleasing, and useful, again, for the generalized movement. No focus on key details like hand positioning, intention, etcetera. Which is something that drawings would be especially useful for, in lieu of photographs.
I guess my frustration is that coming at it from a different martial art style, I wanted more aikido concepts embedded in the explanation of the techniques. "As you are turning here you are joining centers, then projecting him this way off you back foot or whatever" was never in evidence. Which surprised me given the detail that went into defining the "aikido sphere" in the early parts of the book.
It's kind of an examination review manual, this book. The authors have a beautiful chart that list all the techniques, classifying them in all sorts of ways, and attributing them to all sorts of levels of advancement. If ever I have to take a written test on aikido, I'm set. Unfortunately...
Conceptually, I was disappointed in this book. But I was expecting something different. This is, ultimately, a techniques review book, not necessarily for an experienced practitioner looking for insights on refinement or internal development.
|
Excellent background and dynamic drawings, a must for your library if you are a practitioner!
Having just started training in Aikido, I needed a few books to give me the proper background. If one is to own just one, this would be it. There is a lot of ritual in Aikido, and some of it I do not care for, but overall, I believe this to be a very good self defense system, which can be modulated in intensity to correspond to the ferocity of the attacker's energy and intent. The drawings and explanations are very clear, while the theory and tradition is not overwhelming. Highly recommended!
|